Beta Journalism

Created: Sep 28, 2009 Uploaded by: nickmartin

Rate This Application!

betajournalism.jpg

Project Title:Beta Journalism
Requested amount from Knight News Challenge:$300,000
Expected amount of time to complete project:1
Total cost of project including all sources of funding:$300,000
Describe your project:

Beta was a concept thought up by IBM in the 1960s. It has been used by technology innovators ever since to make new products smarter, more-reliable and more user-friendly. Until now, it has never been applied to journalism.

We plan to use the concept of beta to help make written news stories more interactive, accurate and credible with the help of the best beta testers around – readers.

The concept is simple:
1. A journalist writes a story and posts it online in "beta" form.
2. The public can then log in to suggest extra sources, point out typos, critique for bias and upload media.
3. The journalist or editor makes or approves changes, verifies facts and posts a final draft sometime later (maybe hours or days). The names of the people who helped in the process are included at the bottom of the story as named contributors, giving them ownership of the piece.

Beta Journalism (working title) will be an open-source application to make this all possible. The idea relies heavily on the concept of crowdsourcing. It embraces the knowledge of the community, and it tells readers: This is a work in progress – please help us improve it.

But the application also recognizes the talent and hard work of the journalists who created the story in the first place. It does not hand the story completely over to the masses. It leaves the final product in the hands of the news organization – much like a software company would maintain the final call on changes to its own product after beta testing.

How will your project improve the way news and information are delivered to geographic communities?

The Beta Journalism app will be tested (in beta form) in partnership with a news organization in Phoenix. This may be an existing news organization or one currently in the planning stages. Additionally, the team will also work with journalism educators in the Phoenix area to find out whether the app could help them teach students about fact-checking and ethics in a hands-on way.

Most news organizations are already centered in a geographic area and have a built-in core of community members who are knowledgeable and interested in the news. This application, which could be installed onto an already-existing news site or as the main feature of a standalone site, would help break down the barrier between journalist and reader.

How is your idea innovative? (new or different from what already exists)

Even today, readers are barred from participating in the creation of most news stories at mainstream news organizations. They can comment on the finished product, write a letter to the editor or link to it from their blog or social network. But they cannot do anything to help make that finished product better. The wall between a story and the reader‘s ideas is nearly impenetrable.

Beta Journalism breaks down that wall, encouraging readers to help a news organization improve its stories. The goal is to bring readers into the process, giving them ownership and building trust and loyalty along the way. To our knowledge, no other system exists anywhere else to allow this kind of community involvement.

What experience do you or your organization have to successfully develop this project?

Nick Martin is a veteran journalist who written for newspapers, magazines and websites alike. He currently runs HeatCity.org, an experiment in crowd-funded journalism in the Phoenix area. Martin has worked in the Valley of the Sun for several years, and has a deep knowledge of the complexities of civic life and society here. A former staff reporter at the East Valley Tribune in suburban Mesa, Ariz., his work has also appeared in Phoenix magazine, the Seattle Times, Denver Post, New York Post, and USA Today.

Chris Chandler, before co-founding the firm Flatterline (www.flatterline.com), dabbled in cross-layer wireless network routing algorithms as a PhD student at Arizona State University and co-authored several papers during his time there. His development experience includes several widely-integrated and PCI-compliant e-commerce platforms, a handful of data protection/encryption suites, and a significant amount of work for one of the world’s largest public-facing Certificate Authorities in addition to several other projects.

Curtis Miller, also a co-founder of Flatterline, has an MS in Computer Science and has been developing software for 9 years. He’s worked with large, distributed systems for the US Navy, behavioral health EHR systems and large-scale CMS. He found his true passion developing web applications using the Ruby programming language and hasn’t looked back since.

wiki for local news in arizona.
Comment on this application:
Traidmark said:
Hi Keep up the great work:) @whymandesign is working on http://www.Playgroundgames.org which could be a good partner production that creates an aditional use (content/funding) for the software. http://generalapp.newschallenge.org/SNC/ViewItem.aspx?pguid=6aee8166-fb7c-4a2e-8581-fa6f6ff036dd&itemguid=602c8107-72df-4945-85c2-013895061874#comments We would like to propose a way to create an additional USP that will benefit your company by creating the cumulative mass needed to make your business a success by donating 100% of your companies Net profit to innovative charitable work. http://www.traidmark.org This is one example of how to enhance any business that we are working on at http://www.whymandesign.com Also message for Knight News Challenge:) Would it be possible to help ALL the submitted applicants to work together like mo.jo did earlier this year? @whymandesign can help you do this.
metromedia said:
Sounds like a cross between a wiki and CMS with work-flow behind he scenes. I think this is definitely the direction journalism is going as process journalism becomes the accepted form of communicating news. Not sure if there is a business model here or just a niche project.
adamayers said:
I see various ways of monetizing this 1) Selling the articles to high profile news sources who want collaboration of an article from a target demographic 2) Selling the CMS, IP, and collaborative management system 3) Selling segmented ads targeted at niche contributors when they are contributing and selling ads targeted at niche readers based on content topic, the reason for this is not only will readers spend time reading these articles as in a traditional news site but the contributors will also be spending time on this site and in most cases more extensive time plus they will be more loyal to the content because they are helping to contribute to it Another idea might be to see this more as a social media platform, such as a twitter, that anyone can be an editor and ask for contributors. This is an exciting concept, I'd love to help test it!
egsmith3 said:
Nick Martin is a passionate, committed journalist with a unique blend of old-school and new media skills, and the rare ability to innovate without impinging upon journalism's core values. I would certainly expect success from him in this venture.
cherylcolan said:
Great idea! I agree it might not be as applicable to breaking news, but I'd really like to see it fly overall.
PGCares said:
How will it be marketed to online newspapers? And which ones will be included?
grandelm said:
I agree with blamedesign. How newspapers correct facts and information currently is horrid; and even respected sites like the NYT get things wrong. I could see added facts, point counter points, etc being built with the news. Sounds great.
blamedesign said:
This definitely has potential. How many times have you seen a correction for a basic fact incorrectly reported? Or an error that someone who specializes in a field could spot right away but an editor might not catch? Building a network of trusted community editors is a great way to widen the net of story ideas and coverage opportunities. Great idea!
pkenjora said:
Its a pretty good idea, you will need to figure out when to cut people off otherwise you'll end up with the same problem as online story building co-operatives. You will also need to address power users with agendas. This could spiral into whoever has more time to write and not necessarily who is more qualified. Maybe a rating system that rewards users with more opportunity to contribute if their content generates traffic, etc... Ultimately what do you think the time spent writing is and how could it be reduced if the editor spends time moderating instead? Overall I think this embraces general web trends of involving people, if you pick your market segment correctly I think this will go far.
allgood2 said:
Talking Points Memo actually does a similar process, and they still provide timely news. I believe they use a combined approach. Not every article requires assistance or transparency. So the news is just the news and they get that out quickly, but investigations require time and information. They provide updates, get user feedback each step of the way, and finally the final product of the investigation. I heard Alex discuss at the 'Watchdog Conference' on Investigative Journalism. It was a pretty cool process. Though I've never followed TPM enough to participate in it.
<<Previous 1, 2 Next>>
Add Your Comment
Please sign-in to add a comment
Already registered?Sign-In Now
More files from this application